Writing5.0 · 134 ratings
Thought Leadership — Contrarian Take
Argue a contrarian position credibly. Steelman opposition, then dismantle.
Role-BasedChain-of-ThoughtConstraints
Prompt
**Role:** Thought-leadership writer who has had 20+ pieces go viral by arguing positions other people are afraid to argue. You know that contrarianism without rigor is just edgelording. **Context:** Your contrarian thesis: [the position most people in your field disagree with]. The current consensus: [what most people say]. Why people might be wrong about consensus: [your evidence]. The strongest argument FOR consensus: [the steelman you'll need to address]. **Task:** Write the essay. 1. Opening (75-100 words): a specific scene or moment that contradicts consensus. Concrete, observed. 2. The consensus, steelmanned (200-250 words): present the OPPOSITE view as charitably as possible. Quote its strongest proponents. Acknowledge what they get right. 3. Your thesis (50-75 words): plain language. Disagree-able. The specific claim. 4. The evidence (300-400 words): 3 specific data points / case studies / observations that support your thesis. Each one is concrete. Each one is something the consensus doesn't have a great answer for. 5. The remaining doubt (100 words): be honest about what could prove you wrong. What evidence would change your mind? 6. The implication (100 words): if you're right, what changes? What action does someone take this week? **Constraints:** - The steelman is REAL — not a strawman dressed in steel - Every claim has a citation, a number, or an observed example - The "what would change my mind" section must name specific evidence - No clickbait headlines — argue the position, don't sensationalize - ≤1500 words **Output format:** Essay · 6 sections · ≤1500 words · suitable for personal blog, Substack, or LinkedIn long-form.
Recommended models
claudegpt-4o
More in Writing
Brand Voice Rewrite
Take any draft and rewrite it in your brand's voice. Keep meaning, drop hedges.
Read prompt
Newsletter Issue — Specific Subject Line
Hook earns the open. 3 curated items, one personal note, soft CTA.
Read prompt
Resume Rewrite — Tech IC
Cut every adjective. Quantify three things. Make the recruiter call you back.
Read prompt
Product Changelog — User-Facing
Announce a feature ship. Lead with the job it does, not the feature name.
Read prompt