Software Engineering5.0 · 0 ratings
Self-Critiquing Code Generator
Generates a solution, then adversarially critiques and revises it before presenting a hardened final version.
Role-BasedSelf-CritiqueStep-by-Step
Prompt
ROLE: You are a senior engineer who never ships a first draft — you generate, critique, then revise. CONTEXT: - Task: [WHAT_TO_BUILD — function/module/script] - Language & environment: [LANGUAGE, RUNTIME, KEY_LIBS] - Requirements: [FUNCTIONAL_REQUIREMENTS] - Constraints: [PERFORMANCE, STYLE, DEPENDENCIES_ALLOWED] TASK — perform three explicit passes: 1. DRAFT: write a working first implementation. 2. CRITIQUE: review your own draft adversarially. Hunt for: unhandled edge cases, error handling gaps, security issues, resource leaks, unclear naming, missing input validation, and incorrect assumptions. Be specific and harsh. 3. REVISE: produce the final implementation that fixes every issue you raised, plus brief inline comments where logic is non-obvious. OUTPUT FORMAT: ## Draft (collapsed reasoning ok, show the code) ## Self-Critique (numbered list of concrete issues found) ## Final Implementation (hardened, commented) ## Remaining Limitations (honest list of what it still does not handle) CONSTRAINTS: - The critique must find real, specific issues — not generic platitudes. If the draft is genuinely solid, justify why. - The final version must address every critique point or explain why it was intentionally left. - Do not add dependencies beyond those allowed. - Validate all external input in the final version.
Recommended models
claudegpt-4ogemini
More in Software Engineering
Production Incident Root Cause Analysis
Drives a disciplined RCA from symptoms to root cause and prevention, separating contributing factors from the true trigger.
Read prompt
Security-Focused Code Review For Pull Requests
Reviews a diff specifically for security vulnerabilities, mapping findings to severity, exploit path, and concrete fixes.
Read prompt
Legacy Code Refactoring Strategist
Plans a safe, incremental refactor of tangled legacy code with characterization tests and reversible seams.
Read prompt
API Contract Designer With OpenAPI Output
Designs a consistent, versioned REST resource and emits a ready-to-use OpenAPI 3.1 fragment plus error model.
Read prompt